A buyer agrees to your price and insists on paying by PayID. Then an email says the payment is stuck because you need a PayID business account. This guide explains how the scam works, how to check in under a minute, and what to do if you have already sent money.
The short answer: if a buyer says you need a PayID business account, or that you must refund an “upgrade fee” before their payment can arrive, it is a scam. PayID is free. It never emails or texts you directly, and you do not need to upgrade anything to receive money.
That is not our opinion. It is what the banks say. NAB’s warning on the PayID scam targeting people selling items online states that PayID will never send you an email, text or message directly. Westpac’s guide to using PayID and avoiding marketplace scams says PayID is a free service and that you should never be asked to pay a fee to access it.
Key takeaways
- PayID is managed by your bank and costs nothing to use.
- PayID never contacts you directly by email, text or messenger. A message “from PayID” is a scam.
- You never need to pay a fee, or send money first, to receive a PayID payment.
- The only proof that you have been paid is the money in your own account, seen in your banking app.
How the scam unfolds
This scam targets people selling second-hand items on Facebook Marketplace, Gumtree and similar sites. NAB describes the pattern like this:
- A keen “buyer” insists on PayID. They push to pay using PayID and ask for your PayID, which is your mobile number, email address or ABN.
- The payment supposedly “fails”. The buyer says the transfer could not go through because you do not have a PayID “business” account.
- A fake email arrives. It looks like it comes from PayID. It says your account must be upgraded, and it may claim the buyer has already paid extra to cover the “upgrade”.
- You are asked to make things right. The buyer asks you to reimburse the upgrade fee, or to pay it yourself, so the sale can go ahead.
- No money ever arrives. Anything you send goes to the scammer. The original payment never existed.
Defence Bank describes the same scam in its warning about people selling second-hand items online, and repeats the central point: PayID would never contact you directly via email, text or messenger.
What the fake “PayID” email usually looks like
The details change, but the same features come up again and again in bank warnings.
- It claims to be from PayID. That alone settles it. PayID does not send emails, texts or messages to customers. Your bank looks after your PayID.
- It mentions a “business account”, an “upgrade” or a “fee”. A real PayID needs no upgrade to receive money. CHOICE puts it plainly in its guide to PayID scams: PayID does not allow you to pay for “upgrades”.
- It shows an amount larger than your sale price. The extra is presented as the buyer covering the upgrade, with a request to send the difference back.
- It is made to look official. CHOICE notes these emails are designed to look as if they come from a bank or from PayID itself. A logo or a familiar layout proves nothing.
How to check in under a minute
- Do not use anything in the email. No links, no phone numbers, no “confirm” buttons.
- Open your banking app yourself and look at your recent transactions.
- If the money is not in your account, you have not been paid. An email, a screenshot or a message from the buyer does not change that.
- Never send money to receive money. There is no legitimate PayID process that asks for a fee or a refund before a payment arrives.
If you are still unsure, call your bank on the number on the back of your card or on its official website. Do not use a number from the email.
If the buyer also sends a picture of a “successful” transfer, treat it the same way. Our guide to fake PayID and Osko payment screenshots shows why a screenshot is not proof of payment.
Why it works
The story sounds plausible. Business accounts are a real thing at many banks, and refunding someone who “overpaid” feels fair. The scam also arrives at the moment you want the sale to go through.
There is a second reason. The request to send money back is the same trick used in other marketplace frauds. We explain the wider pattern in our guide to overpayment refund scams. In every version, the “overpayment” exists only in a message, never in your account.
Slowing down and checking your own account breaks it.
A safer way to take payment for a marketplace sale
PayID itself is not the problem. It is a normal way to be paid, and the banks quoted above offer it. The risk is in trusting a message about a payment and not the payment itself.
- Agree on the payment method before you meet, and be wary of a buyer who will only use one method and pushes you to hurry.
- Check your own banking app before you hand over the item. Do it while the buyer is still there, or before you post anything.
- Keep the conversation on the marketplace. It leaves a record you can report.
- Walk away from any request to pay first. A real buyer does not need you to send money.
Our checklist on how to verify a payment before shipping covers the same steps for posted items. For the wider set of tricks used on sellers, see our guide to Facebook Marketplace fake payment scams.
If you have already paid or shared details
- Contact your bank immediately, using the number on your card or in your banking app. Funds are hard to recover once they leave your account, so speed matters.
- Report the scam to Scamwatch. Scamwatch is run by the National Anti-Scam Centre at the ACCC. Its report a scam page also says that if your personal or financial information has been stolen, you should contact your bank or card provider straight away and ask them to stop any transactions. It points to IDCARE for support if your identity details were exposed.
- Report the buyer’s profile to the marketplace, as Westpac advises.
- Change your passwords and tell your bank if you gave out personal or login details.
A second opinion on a suspicious email
If you are not sure about an email or message, you can paste its text into the free ScamCheck email checker for a quick read of common scam signs. No tool catches every scam. If in doubt, check with your bank directly.
The bottom line
A PayID business account upgrade is not something a buyer, an email or PayID can ask you for. PayID is free, it does not message you, and it does not hold payments until you pay a fee.
The test is simple. If the money is not in your own account, the sale has not been paid for, and nothing needs refunding.
Frequently asked questions
Does PayID charge fees?
No. PayID is free to use, and you never need to pay to receive money.
Will PayID email me about a payment?
No. PayID does not email, text or message customers directly. Payment information comes through your own bank.
Do I need a PayID business account to sell something?
No. Being told you need an upgrade or a business account before you can be paid is a hallmark of this scam.
The buyer says they paid extra by mistake. Should I refund the difference?
Not on the strength of an email or a screenshot. Check your banking app. If no money has arrived, there is nothing to refund, and the overpayment is part of the scam.
Is it safe to give a buyer my PayID?
A PayID is the mobile number, email address or ABN you registered with your bank so people can pay you. Sharing it is how PayID is meant to work. The scam starts later, when a message claims the payment is stuck and asks you to pay or refund something.
The statements about PayID in this article come from the NAB, Westpac, Defence Bank, CHOICE and Scamwatch pages linked above. This article is educational and is not legal or financial advice. See our disclaimer.
Related reading: Fake PayID and Osko payment screenshots · Overpayment refund scams · Facebook Marketplace fake payment scams · Verify a payment before shipping

